News

NFFN responds to industry memo on meat and dairy

United Kingdom
Dairy
food system
Livestock
nature-friendly farming
supply chain

Large retailers and the supply chain must do more to ensure words on sustainability are backed up with action.


NFFN farmers have spoken out after a group of high-ranking figures from within the food sector said that supply chains and retailers were failing to back up their environmental and climate promises on meat and dairy with action.

The report by Inside Track, titled An Insider’s Guide to Meat and Dairy, claims that while the industry has signed up to commitments on sustainability and health, in practice its commercial strategies favour industrialisation, intensification, and imported cheap foods produced to lower welfare standards.

NFFN farmers say they share much of this frustration, citing challenges including unfair pricing, limited understanding of lower-input and nature-friendly farming systems, and a lack of clear information for shoppers.

NFFN England chair and Cumbrian organic dairy farmer James Robinson said: "Farmers are currently receiving worrying messages from the supply chain. Businesses that once proudly declared their commitment to British meat are now responding to consumer demand by looking to source it from other parts of the world instead.

"When you go to the supermarket, you see large photographs of farmers doing all sorts of wonderful things for food and the environment. While that may be true for a few, most farmers are tied into pricing structures and supply contracts that don't reflect those glossy images.

With prices constantly being forced down, something has to give - and it's usually either animal welfare or environmental standards

James Robinson

"With prices constantly being forced down, something has to give - and it's usually either animal welfare or environmental standards. Our food system currently prizes efficiency and scale, both of which make it very difficult for smaller, nature-friendly, family farms to thrive. What's more, there's little to no support within the current system - whether in food production, supply or government - for mixed farming, which delivers the best outcomes for both nature and farm businesses."

NFFN England steering group member Debbie Wilkins, who runs a mixed farm in Gloucestershire, added: “When nature-friendly farmers join the supply chain of major retailers and food businesses, many of the sustainability incentives inadvertently steer them back towards more intensive forms of production.

"A focus on emissions such as methane can result in animals being kept in sheds and fed bought-in feed to help them reach their final weight more quickly or produce more milk. These systems often fail to recognise the wider benefits of treating farms as ecosystems that support biodiversity, human health and nutrition.

"Much of what is happening across the industry focuses on tweaking highly intensive farming systems, rather than helping farmers make the mindset shift required to transition to regenerative or nature-friendly farming. We also need much clearer differentiation of meat from grass-fed, pasture-fed or high-input systems when it enters the supply chain, so that customers can make informed choices about what they are eating."

Cookie consent

We use cookies on this website to improve your experience, provide social media features, and analyse our traffic. By clicking Accept All, you agree to the use of cookies as outlined in our Cookie & Privacy Policy. You can manage your cookie preferences at any time by clicking Cookie Settings.